No David Cage, more polygons doesn't equal more emotion.

During Sony's unveiling of the Playstation 4 there were a lot of things shown that pointed at the future of videogames.  However, when David Caged walked on stage and said that the solution for bringing more emotion to games is to create characters higher polygon counts, I couldn't help but let out a sigh of disappointment.  Yes, from a technical perspective its great to see the wrinkles on a character's face or see their lips quiver but just because a character looks sad doesn't necessarily mean the player will feel sad.

Two games instantly came to mind while David Cage was giving his presentation.  These games don't graphical push realism but deliver great emotional experiences, TellTale's The Walking Dead and ThatGameCompany's Journey.  Now according to David Cage's logic its impossible for these two games to deliver more emotion than a game like Mass Effect, I disagree. These games, while not graphically powerful, deliver as much if not more emotion than some AAA titles out there.  They do this by building a great world and great characters.

The characters in Journey have no facial features aside from eyes, yet its the most emotional game I've ever played.  It creates emotion through its world with things like level design, color palettes, musical scores, art style and overall game design.  For example, a level thats takes place underground with a dark blue color palette and little to no music elicits a sense of worry.  However a level where you're shot up onto the surface, sunlight blinds the screen, music kicks in and you start to feel relieved and happy. Being introduced to another anonymus player after being alone for a level gives a sense of belonging.  All this from a character with no wrinkles on its face.

The Walking Dead delivers emotion through narrative and dialogue.  The polygon count of The Walking Dead is nowhere near the level of a game like Final Fantasy 13 but I've felt more connection with Lee and Clementine than I did with Vanille or Hope.  What comes out of a character's mouth is more important than how the mouth looks.

Honestly I hope David Cage understands that in order to bring more emotion what needs to change in the next-generation isn't the amount of polygons but the quality of narrative, dialogue and world design.

Views: 800

Tags: 4, cage, david, dead, journey, playstation, the, walking

Comment by Old_School_Gamer on February 27, 2013 at 10:34pm

I would agree. However I do feel detailed "life-like" computer modeled characters, with a better ability to accurately appear to express emotion, can certainly help us feel more empathy (or hate as may be) for the character(s). Of course all that is for waste if the writing and characterization isn't good enough. I do believe Quantic Dreams are capable of a good story and characters.

Comment by Mincho Hristov Ivanov on February 27, 2013 at 10:53pm
David Caged is a joke... all of you know Samurai Jack...right? well the animation is choppy and stuff but maan...it does the job... so mister Caged can put them poligones you know where :D
Comment by Amrit Randay on February 27, 2013 at 11:15pm
Samurai Jack <3 I loved that show!
Comment by Aussie Legend on February 28, 2013 at 3:51am
I cared for the blocks from Thomas Was Alone more than JAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASON. So there, mute point David Cage... mute point.
Comment by Miguel Ramos on February 28, 2013 at 4:31am

He didn't say that. He never said higher polygon count was equal to higher emotion or that it was impossible to convey emotion in lower budget games. He said that it's another tool to express emotion. It's not the only way, but of course the more detail you can put into a performance, easier it is to convey emotion. It's like an actor on film. If you put him behind a mask it's harder to convey emotion. But that doesn't mean that simply showing is whole face will do anything.

Comment by Player One on February 28, 2013 at 6:15am

David Cage is an interesting character. I wish I could say the same for the characters in the games he creates, but c'est la vie.

Comment by Christer Lindqvist on March 1, 2013 at 5:41am

Well written post:)

Personally I can not help feeling like Mr Cage look at me like a lesser person/gamer cause I do like my God of War, or my Prototype (or any other violent game). Same goes for Mr Blow. "Hey you like action and stuff blowing up in games..then you are a shallow dumb ass with no emotional depth"

I am sure thats not how they mean or think of course:)

Thats just the feeling I get.

Dont get me wrong. I love their work. Both of em.

Comment by Alex Lehmann on March 1, 2013 at 3:04pm

Short and to the point, good post. 

While I've only played the first chapter of The Walking Dead (will play it soon!), it certainly got me more interested in the story than Heavy Rain ever managed to do. Actually, one of the reasons I held off on playing The Walking Dead, despite all the praise it got, was because it reminded me so much of Heavy Rain. As it turns out, the concept behind Heavy  Rain wasn't too bad, it was just that the execution and story were not done well. 

To his credit, Cage does try to do things that are a bit different from what everyone else is doing, and for that I respect him, but I just can't help the fact that this guy really annoys me sometimes. 

Comment

You need to be a member of EpicBattleAxe to add comments!

Join EpicBattleAxe

The War Chest

Rankings

The Axe Factor Poll!

How Interested are YOU in playing betas?
I hardly ever touch them0%
I love them, I play as many as I can0%
I treat them kind of like demos0%
I only play them occasionally 0%

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

Community Blogs

EpicBattleCry - Is Violence Getting Too Graphic?

On today's edition of EpicBattleCry we field a question from Sundown (@SundOwn1979) about the realism level in this generation's graphics and the impact they have on the portrayal of violence within interactive entertainment. 

Got a question for the EpicBattleCry crew? Hit us up on Twitter via @EpicBattleAxe and tune in Monday-Friday to find out if your Q gets an A on EBC!…

The Axe Factor 171: Words That End in "eep"

The gates of hell cannot save you from The Axe Factor! This week, we drool over the new Saint's Row, discuss new gameplay from Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, and discuss the importance of betas in shaping games.

-Download-

This Week:

What We’re Watching:…

Axehead Assembly #45: Marie Antoinette's Basement Blues

Prepare to eat a whole mess of cake because the Axehead Assembly is baying at your palace gates with a thirst for strawberry shortcake!

On this week's show we cover Gamescom. Eight games get the full Axehead Assembly treatment including Day Z Standalone, Halo: Master Chief…

EpicBattleCry - Our Best Mutliplayer Experiences

With the highly-anticipated release of Destiny nearly upon us, we kick off this week's EpicBattleCry podcasts with a question from EBA Axehead Rhys Thomas Elliott (@SUPERhys) about our favorite multiplayer experiences. From old-school shooters to more modern sports titles, we evaluate our online (and in-person) multiplayer experiences on today's EBC!

Got a question for the EpicBattleCry crew? Hit us up on Twitter via @EpicBattleAxe and…

Leigh Alexander Gets Fisked

So Leigh Alexander at Gamasutra, Luke Plunkett at Kotaku and Dan Golding (who has written for many places), have written articles on the same day, on the same subject. That's an interesting coincidence. It is also interesting that Chris Plante over at Polygon also had a very similar article, covering the same issues, on the same day though it was written more as a summary of the past week. Now there are time zones to consider but these were all published within 24…

Birthdays

Forum

Diablo Reaper of Souls (PS4)

Started by Jesper Tönning Hansson in Game Discussions 14 minutes ago. 0 Replies

Hi guys,I'm about to finish up the story in Diablo Reaper of Souls, and when I do i would like to have some friends to play adventure mode with.I will probably be finished with the campaign around…Continue

Gaming on the master race

Started by StarBound in Game Discussions. Last reply by PSIII_70R4N on Thursday. 6 Replies

This isn't a thread about PC being better than consoles. It is already a fact, just as a higher frame rate is better than a so called filmic 24 or 30 fps experience. But enough of that, there is…Continue

Yargh...

Started by Axel in Game Discussions. Last reply by Pmpmstrgeneral Aug 20. 1 Reply

Stuck at the very last boss battle of Final Fantasy: The 4 Heroes of Light. All my characters are lvl 99, two black mages one elementalist and a white mage, I got my ass kicked after an intense half…Continue

Star Citizen

Started by Tracy Gates in Game Discussions. Last reply by Tim Albers Aug 20. 5 Replies

I don't know how many space sim players are out there but Ive been keeping an eye on a title called Star Citizen.A rich universe focused on epic space adventure, trading and dogfighting in first…Continue

Tags: massively, multiplayer, sim, space, Roberts

© 2014   Created by Lorin Baumgarten.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service