The Change of Art - A Journey from Stones to Polygons

Yesterday, I had the craziest idea: For the first time in a while, I decided to visit a museum again. Why? I don't know. I guess, I just felt the need to clear my head and expose my mind to different thoughts. What I certainly did not expect, is that this visit would make me reassess my view of video games and their respective place in art history.

Yeah, I was pretty surprised myself.

________________________________________________________________________

Games are art. Well, not all games are. But if you have lived through experiences like Journey, BioShock or Red Dead Redemption, you will find it hard to argue, that the interactive medium is, by all standards, a discipline that can not only be home to incredible aesthetic accomplishments. It is also capable of creating works that transcend their technical limitations and deeply affect the people receiving them.

The funny thing is that the same day of my visit, I had previously played through the first two hours of BioShock Infinite. So, at noon, here I was, standing in the middle of the magnificent treasures of ancient Egypt, the sturdy statues and walls of the Roman Empire, the rich canvas of painters passed; with the memories of the sky-high city of Columbia still fresh in my mind.

It would seem trivial to compare my copy of a product, that you could buy in any software store around the corner, to the irreplaceable legacies of civilizations long lost – Would it not? Well, to be honest, I certainly did not think so.

If someone at a dinner party dared to declare a video game equal to a classic painting, you would hear appalled uproars within a second. People would say that true artists spent hundreds, if not thousands, of hours to create the masterful works that we see in museums today. That brushes and chisels, pens and cameras take years of training, to be put to perfect use; and only then you will even start learning how to tell a story with them.

Now, I would be last person to doubt any of that. As somewhat of an "artist" myself, I can relate to all the unsung pains and ordeals that come with even creating a single coherent piece of work. But guess what? The same holds true for video games.

Do you know how many hours are spent on developing, testing and refining a game like BioShock? Yes, there are over a hundred people employed to work on these kinds of titles, 300 on Bioshock Infinite alone. But those are hundreds of people, that each work thousands of hours on their respective parts of one project. And of course, there are also highly regarded games like Braid or Fez, that were pretty much developed by only one or two people, with at least the same amount of effort from each person.

Also, let's not forget the incredible technical expertise and level of skill it takes, to program lines of code into the digital worlds we see before us. Whether it is graphics, physics, animations, scripting, artificial intelligence or controls – all of that needs to be created, put into context and tuned with every single element of the whole picture.

And that is just the technical side of it. How do you even integrate characters, dialogue and story into all of that? Oh, by the way, that whole gaming thing is interactive. So expect players to screw up your carefully orchestrated experiences on every step of the way.

It's true, that in video games there is rarely one visionary working alone on a singular project. People like Jonathan Blow and Phil Fish certainly pose an exception. But you know what? Those are the times we live in.

We live in an age where information is pouring in so fast, that we rarely place particular value on a singular string of data. There is more content around us, than could ever be perceived by a single person. That's why even art has become a part of an industry that makes experiences a reproducible property printed on a hard piece of media. It has to be a product that can be published, promoted and sold, so we can even realize it is there. Otherwise it would drown in a constant stream of content.

But the fact that we are now able to save and copy, even distribute the collective efforts put into a piece of work, doesn't really diminish the value of art itself. It quite possibly signifies the exact opposite: We can now preserve what was accomplished by great women and men, capture it in capsules devoid of time, never to be lost again.

What once were the stones that our forefathers used to carve their imaginations into, now are the polygons from which we build our virtual worlds. We may mold digital bits and bytes, instead of shaping concrete materials with our hands. But the goal is really the same: We bend a medium to our will, in order to create something that is somehow reminiscent of, but also a lot larger than life itself. However, these days, our dreams are potentially forged for eternity.

So, in a way, art actually has changed. But that's not necessarily a bad thing.

Views: 58

Tags: Art, BioShock, Blow, Braid, Dead, Fez, Fish, Games, Infinite, Jonathan, More…Journey, Phil, Red, Redemption, Video, no, spoilers

Comment by Docwoor on March 29, 2013 at 9:28am

Art is a reflection, critique and whatnot of society, so it should change and evolve!

Nicely written mate!

Comment by Christoph Zeis on March 29, 2013 at 4:24pm

Highly agreed. Thanks for reading!

Comment by Alex Lehmann on March 30, 2013 at 7:34pm

Well written.

I will say though; I'm feeling a bit tired of this constant debate of whether or not video games are art. I just feel that art is something that engages on a deeper level, that either touches you or makes you reflect. When it is clear that games can do this, then what really is the argument for games not being art? Besides, we've pretty much had this very same discussion for over 50 years when film was emerging.

Comment by Christoph Zeis on March 31, 2013 at 1:54am

I feel like it always will be an ongoing discussion.

Of course, you are very right on film going through the same struggles and growing pains. It seems like every new medium has to go through these transitional periods of being "accepted" by the main audience, or at least trying to "justify" its status as a legitimate pastime.

Just the fact that we are having this constant discussion, even from the side of game developers, probably shows a certain kind of insecurity on part of the gaming industry itself. I mean, that is pretty much what people like David Cage and Ken Levine try to illustrate all the time.

Thanks for your comment!

Comment

You need to be a member of EpicBattleAxe to add comments!

Join EpicBattleAxe

The War Chest

Rankings

The Axe Factor Poll!

Do YOU Enjoy The Content (Not Policy) of DLC?
Yes. I find DLC really enhances a game0%
Rarely. I've only seen a handful of examples of good DLC0%
No. I never find anything of value in DLC0%
Usually. Most of the time DLC is pretty good.0%

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

Community Blogs

The Axe Factor 174: A Passive-Agressive Ball of Yarn

Definitive graphics cannot save you from The Axe Factor! This week, we talk over Triad Wars, the Sleeping Dogs Definitive edition, and the abysmal state of DLC.

-Download-

This Week:

What We’re Watching:

Triad Wars - Welcome to the…

EpicBattleCry - With Titan Cancelled, Are MMOs Dead?

We've got the cure for your case of Mondays, EpicBattleCry! Today, @gargaflaps asks if the cancellation of Blizzards long-gestating game Titan heralds a turn in the industry away from large scale MMOs.

Got a question for the EpicBattleCry crew? Hit us up on Twitter via @EpicBattleAxe and tune in Monday-Friday to find out if your Q gets an A on EBC!

Subscribe to…

Axe Lords & Axehead Army Round Table...!!

After hearing about the news of EBA discontinuing in about another 50 episodes I wonder how far into the future that puts us time wise. 

More importantly I am sad and to be very honest with you I feel like something great would die. This gaming community has more spirit and intelligent conversation to offer than any other..!

Heres what I think.....

We need to have an adobe video conference..!!
>> http://j.mp/1yvRjRK

I…

Thank you EBC Crew

Just finished listening to the last episode of EBC and very saddened by your anouncement. I've been a loyal listener since the very beginning and a big fan of the show. Thanks for the many hours of epic podcasts and the many years of entertainment you gave us.

Even though you don't even know me at all, I feel like I got to know you guys so well over the years. It really is so much more than just loosing a podcast, we are loosing 3 great friends that we hung out with every…

Building my own Prison from scratch (A Prison Architect Preview)

Two weeks ago the Humble Bundle Indie Bundle 12  was released and seeing how many great games made it into the Bundle i couldn't resist and added another unnecessary amount to my vast Steam game collection a.k.a. "games that will never been played but are nice to have". Well aware of the existing gems in the Bundle like Gone…

Forum

What has Epic Battle Cry meant to you?

Started by Michael Esguerra in Site Discussions. Last reply by Lucius Silver yesterday. 5 Replies

I'm kind of surprised that no one has started this topic yet, but with the recent announcement of Epic Battle Cry coming to an end, I thought a lot of people, like me, would like to share their…Continue

Tags: EpicBattleCry, Cry, Battle, Epic, End

Another Euclidean Tech Demo (VR Ready?)

Started by DefGeoff256 in Game Discussions. Last reply by best_jeppe on Thursday. 1 Reply

I don't usually go to Kotaku for much of anything, but a friend passed this on to me as a follow up to a past demo by this group regarding "Infinite Detail."While I still remain extremely dubious as…Continue

Tags: oculus, rift, Games, Graphics, Infinite

Calling All Guardians: Are You Ready To Represent?

Started by Abberjam in Game Discussions. Last reply by CrazyDays on Thursday. 10 Replies

Are you ready for Destiny? I mean really ready?? - You may think you are, but let me tell you my friend, you aren't fully equipped to tackle the dangers of the solar system until you have your…Continue

Misogyny

Started by Carnex in Off-Topic Discussions. Last reply by Averagus on Thursday. 3 Replies

Let me start with that I'm following this circus since it's debut on Gametrailers. I wanted to write many times but time and my writing on several other forums and publications ate my time and will…Continue

Tags: compaint, gender, Misogyny

© 2014   Created by Lorin Baumgarten.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service